← Back to context

Comment by imp0cat

10 months ago

Just read the Google Play reviews, the app still has a long way to go to be usable.

But it's still a great idea.

Also, they should calculate both the calories and power requirements for each meal analyzed. What I mean is, it should says something like: this burger has 800 kcal and the analysis consumed 1kw of datacenter power. ;)

> But it's still a great idea.

No, it isn't, because it can never work. It is, in general, impossible to determine the calorie content of food by looking at a picture of it.

kw is an instantaneous measurement. Energy usage would be kWh (kilowatt-hours). Considering it would take a tiny fraction of a server’s compute for less than a second this would be very small.

>But it's still a great idea.

Define "great".

It has $2m revenue, so it's clearly a great idea (at this stage?) financially and 'people love it' (30% retention)

Technically it's a garbage idea, and I'd say they could get class-actioned without good T&Cs. It's literally impossible to determine the sugar and fat content of a meal.

I'd never make it for the latter reason, however you clearly need to believe in the former to make it big haha.

  • 30% retention means that 70% of people who have paid for it didn't consider it valuable enough to pay for.

    The $2m figure is unverified but, even if it was, turnover is meaningless without knowing their expenses. If they're burning through £2.1m in LLM compute and marketing then they're losing money.

    Plus, the guy seems like a dick so I'm taking his story with an enormous pinch of salt.