← Back to context

Comment by mkoubaa

13 days ago

Would you say that the atom bomb project was held hostage by a couple of technical physicists?

Obviously it can't succeed (in the desired time frame) without those specific people, and pretending like it can is lunacy.

Functionally 0% of companies are working on things as important or impactful as the atom bomb, and I include FAANG et al in that. Maybe a small handful of AI companies will actually put out something that important? But even most of them won't.

The vast majority of companies are putting web forms over a database. Letting one or two people hold all the technical knowledge for something like that is borderline fiduciary negligence.

  • That isn't the point; It's not about the importance

    It's about specialized knowledge. To the owners of the business, making sure the business doesn't fail to deliver is existentially important.

    Web developers are fungible. The guy who designed the carefully tuned graph database that runs on a custom Linux kernel with a custom tuned filesystem is not. If this sort of thing is critical to your business succeeding, that engineer might as well be Niels Bohr.

    • My point is 90% of companies have no specialized knowledge whatsoever and are staffed almost entirely by web developers.

      How many companies have an in-house tuned graph database? How many companies have custom Linux kernels? How many companies have custom filesystems?

      1 reply →