Comment by cies
2 months ago
We should outright forbid it in public space. IHMO.
Also I'd say lets only tax undesirable behaviour!
So not tax:
* wages
* having a house
* adding value (VAT)
But so tax:
* land use
* polluting
* packaging (could be part of polluting)
* accumulating profits at the top
This idea has some similarities to:
Totally agree on taxing undesirable behavior--everyone complains about 'traffic' and the potential traffic impacts of something. If noise/pollution was taxed appropriately perhaps traffic would be less of a concern. A government needs to get revenue somehow and wages are just a very convenient way to do so. However, with all the modern technology that we have now, I think there are options available that are not being taken (such as fair land use tax with computer calculated values)
TIL about Georgism! Thanks. This is why I like HN discussions.
> We should outright forbid [advertising] in public space. IHMO.
My cousin died to protect your right to say this. Ads are speech too.
It's totally established precedent that billboards, signs, etc are limited. Whether they should be or not, I'm not sure, but that's how it is currently: https://firstamendment.mtsu.edu/article/billboards/#:~:text=...
Are limited liability companies people ? Because to me, it seems they are considered people when it's beneficial, and not when it's not. Weird.
I think free speech is something to protect for humans, not for companies.
I can say "you should get the vaccine!" Companies that want to say these kinds of things have rules to abide by: and thanks fully so.
I'm much for free speech, but more in the sense that we should be able to discuss policy/politics/critique/bitch/bash/religions/etc. Not so we can make terror plans, defame, harass, bully and share child porn.
Not sure what happened to your cousin... But I'm curious now. Care to share?
> I'm much for free speech, but more in the sense that we should be able to discuss policy/politics/critique/bitch/bash/religions/etc. Not so we can make terror plans, defame, harass, bully
The recent past should tell you that a lot of what some would call legitimate critique/bitch/bash etc. others would call harass/bully/violence –to also include not speaking about it at all.
So in the interest of consistency, and publicity, I'd prefer to let the bigots of the world speak, and out themselves as bigots, so that we may then publicly speak and make fun of them for being bigots. The same goes for corporations.
1 reply →
> Not sure what happened to your cousin... But I'm curious now. Care to share?
My cousin served in the Armed Forces "to protect your freedom" (his words). The fact that he died during training maneuvers, does not detract from that.
3 replies →