← Back to context

Comment by rtp4me

6 days ago

Because investment income is not the same as wage income. Nor should they be.

Why not? Money is fungible. A dollar is a dollar. Why should investment dollars be taxed less than those earned through the sweat of one's brow?

  • Mainly to encourage people to save their money. You know, "work smarter, not harder"...

    • Financial policy is very specifically against people saving their money though - that's why a certain level of inflation is considered desirable to mainstream economists. Spending and borrowing is heavily encouraged at all levels, while investment opportunities are gated based on wealth and income to prevent the poor from being able to "work smarter".

      9 replies →

    • We have tax-advantaged retirement accounts to enable the middle class to save a reasonable amount in order to retire without being a burden on society. A typical saver doesn't have additional extra money leftover for a taxable brokerage account that exposes them to capital gains taxes.

      Low capital gains taxes aren't meaningfully encouraging somebody making 75k and saving 10k annually to continue with their saving plan.

    • So you tax the person extra who needs to eat their money, and let the person who is swimming in money keep more of it?

      And you earnestly can't understand why the poor want to increase taxes on the rich?