← Back to context

Comment by bennofs

8 hours ago

8MWh is equivalent to a few hours of electricity generation of a wind turbine.

Kuala Lumpur gets (generous assumption) about 100 lightning strikes per square kilometer per year [0].

If a single drone could service a lot of square km, then it could conceivably collect a lot of electricity. E.g. if it could service 20 square km: 20 * 100 * 8mWh = 16gWh per year. Not bad, but an upper bound, and it hinges a lot on that first parameter (service area).

[0] https://forum.lowyat.net/topic/5376210/all

  • You need ~4 strikes per hour to keep up with a single large offshore wind turbine (15MW at 40% capacity factor).

    That would mean 350km² just to match a single wind turbine (at 100% capture efficiency for 5GJ lightning strikes).

    This is not ever gonna make economical sense.

    • True that an offshore wind turbine can produce 15MW. But it can cost $100m+ just for 1 turbine (built and installed). If drones are going up anyway (to protect a city/citizens from strikes), then electricity generation is effectively free, and the marginal cost is equal to the hardware required to capture it (maybe relatively low).

      3 replies →