Comment by mark242
21 hours ago
Roam has always felt like a bit of a chore -- while it's easy enough to set up backlinks, having to do that one step has always been like a waste of time to me. This is the kind of thing that imo an agentic workflow could do for you:
- Just start typing
- Let the LLM analyze what you're typing, given the RAG database of everything else you've added, and be able to make those kinds of correlations quickly.
- One-button approve the backlinks that it's suggesting (or even go Cursor-style yolo mode for your backlinks).
Then, have a periodic process do some kind of directed analysis; are you keeping a journal, and want to make sure that you're writing enough in your journal? Are you talking about the same subjects over and over again? Should you mix things up? Things like that would be perfect for an LLM to make suggestions about. I don't know if Roam is thinking of doing this or not.
But... backlinks are fully automated. If you just make forward-links that you'd normally do in the course of writing.
You're thinking of an optional step of adding extra links "just because", but IMO that's as a learning process in the beginning when you're not used to adding any forward-links whatsoever.
Yes.
IMO the 3 table-stakes features for a notetaking app in 2025 are AI-powered search (including a question-answering capability), showing related / recommended notes (via RAG), and automated clustering (K Means + LLM) to maintain a category hierarchy.
I think this might be the most exciting use-case of LLM's I've seen suggested here. I've struggled with exactly this problem with note-taking and personal knowledge-bases.
I'm not a huge fan of bringing AI into everything but as I was reading the blog post, it did feel like this is the place where it belongs.
I'd love to have this but only if it runs entirely on my own machine or on a server I own. Uploading all my notes to somebody else's cloud is a nonstarter.
Can Ollama do this yet?