← Back to context

Comment by exiguus

21 hours ago

I concur and generally advise against using large corporate DNS providers. Instead, consider setting up your own DNS infrastructure, such as your own recursive servers, or opt for a trustworthy DNS provider like Freifunk or CCC, rather than Google, Cloudflare, or Quad9.

The advantages of self-hosting recursive servers include complete configurability, absence of censorship, tracking, and rate limits. However, like any self-hosting solution, it requires an investment of time and money. It's also important to note that DNS lacks an authentication layer, so for access restrictions, it should be placed within a private network or VPN.

The issue of pre-configured DNS over HTTPS (DoH) in many browsers and mobile devices can be addressed through firewall rules on your router.

For creating your own DNS infrastructure, I recommend dnsdist if you have ample time, though bind and unbound are also viable options.

For the past three years, I have been running dnsdist with recursive servers on two ARM VPS instances, costing around 14 EUR per month. This setup provides me with DNS over TLS (DoT), DoH, and other features. I use them with unbound (TLS) or dnsproxy and dnscrypt-proxy across routers, servers, and other machines. For mobile devices, I utilize DoH directly.

Previously, I used bind in recursive mode without any encryption beyond SSH tunneling or VPN.

Alternatively, I can recommend ffmuc as a DNS provider.

I also run my own recursive DNS server on a VPS I rent, but I freely share it with other users of the Internet. This causes my "personal" signal of queries to authoritative servers to effectively disappear, and I also (marginally) benefit from caching effects of other users' lookups.