← Back to context

Comment by panzi

6 days ago

I'd say: Don't use the shell if what you want to do is to execute another program.

You don't need to handle any quoting with exec*(). You still need to handle options, yes. But under Windows you always have to to handle the quoting yourself and it is more difficult than for the POSIX shell and it is program dependent. Without knowing what program is executed you can't know what quoting syntax you have to use and as such a standard library cannot write a generic interface to pass arguments to another process in a safe way under Windows.

I just felt it sounded like POSIX is particularly bad in that context, while in fact it is better than Windows here. Still, the system() function is a mistake. Use posix_spawn(). (Note: Do not use _spawn*() under Windows. That just concatenates the arguments with a space between and no quoting whatsoever.)

>Still, the system() function is a mistake. Use posix_spawn().

They are entirely different interfaces though. If you'd implemented system() using posix_spawn() it'd be just as bad as system()