Comment by thih9
6 months ago
> emits text in these ranges that was AI generated
How would you define AI generated? Consider a homework and the following scenarios:
1. Student writes everything themselves with pen & paper.
2. Student does some research with an online encyclopedia, proceeds to write with pen and paper. Unbeknownst to them, the online encyclopedia uses AI to answer their queries.
3. Student asks an AI to come up with the structure of the paper, its main points and the conclusion. Proceeds with pen and paper.
4. Student writes the paper themselves, runs the text through AI as a final step, to check for typos, grammar and some styling improvements.
5. Student asks the AI to write the paper for them.
The first one and the last one are obvious, but what about the others?
Edit, bonus:
6. Student writes multiple papers about different topics; later asks an AI to pick the best paper.
7. Student spent the entire high school and bachelor's degree learning from content that teachers generate using AI and using it to do homework, hence becoming AI-contaminated
This is about the characters themselves, therefore:
1. Not AI 2. Not AI 3. Not AI 4. The characters directly generated by AI are AI characters 5. AI 6. Not AI
The student dictates a paper word for word exactly
The student is missing arms and so dictates a paper word for word exactly
Voice-to-text would probably not classify as an LLM
3 replies →
6 is extremely interesting, in that it's tantamount to asking a panel of innumerably many people to give an opinion on which paper is best for a general audience.
It's hard to imagine that NOT working unless it's implemented poorly.