Comment by whensean
5 days ago
From the perspective of national and social development, this is definitely a dross culture. This system similar to hierarchy seemingly increases the courtesy among people. However, it more often leads to age bullying, blind obedience to the elders, and hinders resistance and innovation.
Influenced by Confucian culture, China doesn't have such a perverted etiquette system at all.
Typical cultural superiority bias.
Every way has its pros and cons. Having an age related hierarchy might have benefits like societal coherence or stability. I am not a proponent of it, I just acknowledge my inability to fully grasp the impact and ramifications as to label one as superior and the other as "perverted".
>benefits like societal coherence or stability
The situation looks exactly the opposite if you look at the birth rate in the Korea.
I obviously did not mean numerical stability.
In the modern day, Korean culture is absolutely cooked. There is a reason their birth rates are so terrible. Talking to Koreans and consuming even just a little bit of media about Korea makes some of the problems pretty obvious.
If you think hierarchy is natural and good you're a conservative or some other kind of reactionary.
Hierarchies invite revolt and need a lot of force to keep in place.
I did not talk about natural, I did not talk about good.
If you think there are no hierarchies everywhere, then we have a completely different worldview.
1 reply →
[flagged]
I will point you again to the usage of the word "perverted", which you missed twice.
Additionally the bias I pointed out is highly relevant to the discussion and therefore my argument is not an ad hominem. I can wait for you to calm down if you'd like, so your next reply is less emotionally charged. (that one was.)