← Back to context

Comment by metrix

6 days ago

Can you explain?

Historically, "safety" referred to protection from physical harm. It has now expanded into psychological, emotional, economical realms. This had the (very much intended) effect of redefining "unsafe" from imminent and persistent threat to anything that makes me uncomfortable.

  • In America, in many states, you can be imprisoned for having an abortion.

    Sharing your menstrual data and therefore having it available for subpoena is quite literally a physical safety risk.

    If you don't understand, or disagree that the word "safety" is entirely appropriate here, can you talk about why?

    • > If you don't understand, or disagree

      I understand, and I do agree. I simply answered the GPs question.

  • Not sure how that's super relevant here? "my data could be used to accuse me of a crime" is a threat of physical harm anyway, unless you define being arrested as safe.

    And I don't really think public opinion has shifted on that part. You could argue about emotional comfort or something, maybe.

When your ideologies don't stand on their own merit, one last resort is to redefine words (and hope nobody notices) in order to force people to believe what you say.