Comment by infecto
3 days ago
It’s actually quite common. You have base load generation stations and your highly variable solar and wind. There are often times when the power at a wholesale rate dips below zero. It’s too costly to turn off your base load plants and maybe both solar and wind are generating above normal.
Solar inverters can just not draw the solar current, and wind can generally just change the pitch on their rotors at the individual level. The only ones that generally can not help ‘over produce’ are baseload power stations as they have actual physical inertia in very large turbines and can’t respond as quickly to demand.
Baseload power stations sometimes over-produce on longer timescales than just a few seconds because they'd rather not turn them off for maintenance/operational reasons. E.g. imagine you have a big biomass boiler feeding a steam turbine. Turning it off for an hour or two means everything cools down, which is a thermal stress, reducing lifetime compared to keeping it at constant power.
But yes, certainly poorly managed solar/wind that doesn't have good mechanisms to turn off in response to lack of demand is mainly the issue. In the future, when control systems are better, I'm sure negative pricing will be much less common.
Right but keep in mind these events are generally short lived and depending on the market there may be reliability guarantees that keep these open or specific federal funding rates.
But like I said before when rates go negative you will typically see it in occurrences where you have abnormal conditions (wind and solar generating at the same time) or aggressive night winds. And it does not happen long enough to need to curtail generation.