Comment by jandrese
4 days ago
Sabine is an asshole. Doesn't mean she is wrong, and I appreciate when she reads some paper that has made a bunch of headlines to figure out if they're full of crap or not (spoiler alert: the answer is usually yes), but while she can identify the problem she's not part of the solution. Her divorce from academia means she has little power to affect change for the better given how the incentives are currently aligned. She can make a lot of noise, but the people actually pulling the levers have rigged the system in their favor enough to not care.
So she is an arsehole for exposing bullshit? I don't see the problem. I think people take issue with her because of her confrontational persona.
>while she can identify the problem she's not part of the solution
Does she have to be, in principle?
> Her divorce from academia means she has little power to affect change for the better given how the incentives are currently aligned.
Wouldn't be so sure about that. She is getting more public exposure than most academic would in their lifetime. More importantly, exposure to audience _outside_ of academia. Voters. Her effort in creating public awareness has certainly stirred the nest in some academic circles.