← Back to context

Comment by samtheprogram

2 days ago

This isn’t reasoning at all. It’s applying a well known algorithm to a problem. It literally says “classic” in its response.

5 comments

samtheprogram

Reply
janalsncm  2 days ago

It is “reasoning” in the same way that a calculator or compiler is reasoning. But I checked the solution, it’s actually wrong so it’s a moot point.

  • CamperBob2  2 days ago

    What will really bake your noodle is when you realize that just because the model's answer is wrong doesn't mean it didn't use reasoning to reach it.

    Is your reasoning always perfect? No? Ever get partial credit on a test question in school? Yes? Well, maybe don't expect perfection from a model that didn't exist 5 years ago, that was considered impossible 10 years ago, and that would have gotten you burned as a witch 15 years ago.

    Nobody claims that o3-pro is AGI, or even that it is going to lead up to AGI.