Comment by Groxx
3 days ago
tbh I'm not quite sure if you're arguing in favor of switching to "it's" or against. I think against...?
Clearly "x is" is most consistent in that example, implying the possessive form is inconsistent.
Also clearly in a straightforward example
John possesses -> John's
The dog possesses -> Dog's
It possesses -> It's
Xe possesses -> Xe's
is equally as consistent as "x is", which is more consistent than "Its".
(yes I'm aware there's a proper noun vs pronoun change in there, but I'm not sure that's an argument for "special noun cases are good". they undeniably exist, but should we encourage them?)
No comments yet
Contribute on Hacker News ↗