Comment by pixl97
2 days ago
Evolution is messy and guided by random occurrences.
Early in the internet days I had ran an open SMTP server for a few years before it was used as a spam relay. The web browser didn't have a security model. Online shopping was going up to a site, writing what you wanted on paper, then mailing off a money order.
Then both fraud and useful things like actual online shopping started happening while the size of the web exploded. Masses of people with no technical capability were getting online. And that's before we got to the age of social media and massive data collection.
Simply put we didn't make the 'web' part of the internet, some people tossed it out as a child and it's been a tooth and nail fight for survival ever since, patching itself up one vuln at a time.
never mind the fact that half these captchas are just excuses for orgs to sneakily extract some reinforcement learning data from you. last time I tried to sign into my microsoft account it made me do 6 captchas. SIX. not six like I failed 1 captcha six times, six like each captcha was iteratively marked i/6
Most of the time you get captcha failures like that it's because you're also doing things that are good for your security like blocking all kinds of 3rd party bullshit. I've had to do things like turn off adblock on a page to get past the captcha before turning it back on.
it wasn't a failure, but I do see what you're saying