← Back to context

Comment by intended

2 days ago

I am making a defense of economics, not capitalism.

I like markets, and would laugh if anyone went ahead and tried to make a purely capitalistic economy. Fair, well regulated economies, work.

>Fair, well regulated economies, work

There is not a single fair, well regulated economy in the world. Private interests of those with large amounts of capital skew the markets to their favor.

  • This is a nirvana fallacy. “There aren’t any that are perfect so why try?”

    How fair and well regulated is not a binary option of it is or it isn’t and we can continuously try to make things better.

    • >we can continuously try to make things better

      Who is "we" here? Because the current system is ran by people who have a vested interest in keeping things the same.

      Also, I disagree on my comment being a fallacy. I'd almost argue the comment I replied to is a fallacy because it's comparing a theoretical well regulated market to the reality of what we actually have.

      It's clear to me that such a thing could never truly work because it would require near omnipotence by whomever the regulating body is in order to prevent actors gaming the market.