← Back to context

Comment by WarOnPrivacy

2 days ago

> Does your right to hear anyone's speach

The rights are that Gov shall make no law prohibiting speech and assembly.

By extension, Gov shall not perform actions in response to speech and assembly, because the laws to authorize those actions shall not exist.

Yes, but this person arrived from another country. Would you say freedom of speech and freedom of assembly means that people from around the world have the right to assemble in the United States?

  • > Yes, but this person arrived from another country.

    Yes.

    > Would you say freedom of speech and freedom of assembly means that people from around the world have the right to assemble in the United States?

    I wouldn't say that because it isn't a well formed question. It conflates multiple, distinct activities. It unhelpfully presents them as if they were a single, constitutionally addressable action, which they are not.

    • But he was denied entry at the border, so it appears that, according to you, anyone from elsewhere in the world should be able to assemble in the US and express his free speech.