Comment by WarOnPrivacy
21 hours ago
> Had he been denied entry at point of departure, would that have been ok?
You are asking how I'd feel if a foreign government took some action against him at their border?
This question is fairly far afield; it would be a wholly different discussion.
So it does seem to me that this this person should be in the US due to a technicality?
It it an actuality and not a not a technicality. The reasons remain the same as the last time you made the assertion. Also for the next time.
You've been heading toward the farthest boundary of good faith discussion for some time now. At this point, I think you are signaling that you have crossed it.
If the person had his visa cancelled, then the ideal way would have been to not let him on the plane at point of departure. As this didn't happen then the next location entry can be denied is at the border within the destination airport, and he was denied entry there. If you argue that he has landed, is on US soil, is handled by US law enforcement, then are you also saying that regardless of whether this person has a visa or not, he should be let assembled in the United States regardless of the visa status?