Comment by holowoodman
2 months ago
Security bugs always have a context-dependent severity. An availability problem in a medical device is far more severe than a confidentiality problem. In a cloud service, the same problems might switch their severity, downtime isn't deadly and just might affect some SLAs, but disclosing sensitive data will yield significant punishment and reputation damage.
That is why I think that "severity" and the usual kinds of vulnerability scores are BS. Anyone composing a product or operating a system has to do their own assessment, taking into account all circumstances.
In the context of the original article this means that it is hopeless anyways, and the maintainer's point of view is valid: in some context everything is "EXTREMELY HIGH SEVERITY, PANIC NOW!". So he might as well not care and treat everything equally. Absolutely rational decision that I do agree with.
No comments yet
Contribute on Hacker News ↗