← Back to context

Comment by meepmorp

7 months ago

SONET is widely used in the US.

Used, maybe, but [citation needed].

Built, no, definitely not voluntarily¹, Ethernet is the only non-legacy thing surviving for new installations for anything more than short range (few kilometer) runs. InfiniBand, CPRI and SDI are dying too and getting replaced with various over-Ethernet things, even for low-layer line aggregation there's FlexE these days.

¹ some installations are the exception confirming the rules; but as a telco sinking more money into keeping an old SONET installation alive is totally the choice of last resort. You'll have problems getting hardware too.

Disclaimer: I don't know what military installations do.

  • Infiniband is alive and well in HPC. 327 out of the top 500 machines use it according to this:

    https://www.top500.org/statistics/sublist/

    It is a nice interconnect. It is a shame that the industry does not revisit the idea of connecting all components of a computer over infiniband. Nvlink fusion is a spiritual successor in that regard.

    • Yes, IB hasn't died… yet. But the writing's probably on the wall with Ultra Ethernet; the corporate development of Mellanox (now nVidia) is not a great sign either.

      (Also you don't use IB for 1800km WAN links.)

      FWIW I actually run IB and think it's a nice interconnect too :)

      5 replies →