Comment by timr
4 days ago
On the contrary, this is such a common misunderstanding that it practically defines the meme of pop science.
Proposal of a hypothesis is not answering. Even if, decades from now and after many additional studies, scientific consensus settles on this hypothesis as "the answer", the first paper to speculate about the idea is still just a speculation. Moreover, if you're an outsider, the speculation is often an idea that's been floating around the field for longer than you've been aware of it.
Basically, just abandon your notion that there is "an answer" to any sufficiently complex scientific question, and you will be better off.
It sounds like you're just dead set on defending the rude way of dismissing someone's comment? "Might just have been answered" is a completely valid description of what happened: the correct hypothesis might have been produced. It is obvious to anyone that it still requires verification; producing an answer is not the same as proving it beyond a shadow of doubt, and no one said it was. You're pretending to debate some philosophy of science but actually are playing pedantic word games to sound smart or gatekeep or something.