from which perspective? I have yet to wrap my head around it(this usually means I am wrong about something), but there may be no singularity because it takes matter an infinite amount of time to reach the center due to time dilation effects.
This is the origin of my favorite science fiction theory. (little to no actual science but you could write a fun space romp around it) If you get a large enough black hole where the tidal forces will not rip you to shreds instantly, you could just scoot across the event horizon right, now what happens? you can still move around, everything feels normal, but really you have lost half a dimension, everything "out" from the center is completely gone from the universe. Now the theory, back to our universe, What happened to time? why does time only go one way? we can accelerate and decelerate along the time axis, but can't reverse it. Where has our missing half of a time dimension gone?
>To an external observer, an object falling into a black hole appears to slow down and never actually crosses the event horizon, seemingly freezing in time.
It takes infinite time to reach event horizon, not the center.
Yeah, that is the tricky part. The problem is that black holes are eldritch interstellar cryptids, and for the most part physics gives up and goes to cry in the corner the minute you start asking about "what's in a black hole?"
But in this specific case, you get one odd conclusion. if it takes forever to enter a black hole. is it impossible for anything to pass the event horizon? It sounds like this is observation dependent. but from an external point of view you are unable to observe anything entering the black hole. and from an internal point of view, the universe will instantly age and die when you try and enter the hole.(and if hawking radiation actually exists you will see the black hole shrink and pop the instant you try and enter it) either way nothing is getting in.
Is most of the mass of the star that formed the black hole actually stuck in a time dilated shell just outside the event horizon? Or perhaps all the mass is eternally stuck collapsing. and never actually reaches the density required to pass the event horizon. is that another way to define the event horizon? the point where time stops.
It's not quite true that everything feels normal. If I am standing with my feet toward the singularity, my hand cannot move above my head, the best it can do is fall toward the singularity slower than my head does. Especially at very slow speeds this has some very weird physical effects, not the least of which is the immediate impossibility of all systems that make you 'you' continuing to function.
My understanding is that for extremely large black holes the tidal forces are negligible near the event horizon. So things should function pretty much the same other than you can't move in reverse and get out.
If two rockets fall past the horizon at the same time, one accelerating forward towards the singularity, and the other accelerating backwards away from the singularity, then shouldn't the distance between the rockets increase, even though they are both moving inexorably forward?
If the tidal forces are low, I'd assume that my muscles are still strong enough to "slow down my hand enough" to move it above my head.
The black hole has two conceptual parts - the event horizon and the singularity. The event horizon is a one-way imaginary shell where once you pass it, you will end up at the singularity which is a point at the center of the event horizon. It’s the hole in black hole. Because the radius of the spherical horizon grows linearly with mass, but the size of the hole is fixed at effectively 0, it allows for a bit of sightseeing on your way to impending doom if the mass of the hole is large enough.
One of the more mind bending aspects of this is how the horizon becomes inescapable. The singularity is the only “forward” that exists anymore. You cannot conceivably go anywhere else. Every direction becomes “in”.
from which perspective? I have yet to wrap my head around it(this usually means I am wrong about something), but there may be no singularity because it takes matter an infinite amount of time to reach the center due to time dilation effects.
https://modern-physics.org/time-dilation-near-massive-bodies...
This is the origin of my favorite science fiction theory. (little to no actual science but you could write a fun space romp around it) If you get a large enough black hole where the tidal forces will not rip you to shreds instantly, you could just scoot across the event horizon right, now what happens? you can still move around, everything feels normal, but really you have lost half a dimension, everything "out" from the center is completely gone from the universe. Now the theory, back to our universe, What happened to time? why does time only go one way? we can accelerate and decelerate along the time axis, but can't reverse it. Where has our missing half of a time dimension gone?
>To an external observer, an object falling into a black hole appears to slow down and never actually crosses the event horizon, seemingly freezing in time.
It takes infinite time to reach event horizon, not the center.
Yeah, that is the tricky part. The problem is that black holes are eldritch interstellar cryptids, and for the most part physics gives up and goes to cry in the corner the minute you start asking about "what's in a black hole?"
But in this specific case, you get one odd conclusion. if it takes forever to enter a black hole. is it impossible for anything to pass the event horizon? It sounds like this is observation dependent. but from an external point of view you are unable to observe anything entering the black hole. and from an internal point of view, the universe will instantly age and die when you try and enter the hole.(and if hawking radiation actually exists you will see the black hole shrink and pop the instant you try and enter it) either way nothing is getting in.
Is most of the mass of the star that formed the black hole actually stuck in a time dilated shell just outside the event horizon? Or perhaps all the mass is eternally stuck collapsing. and never actually reaches the density required to pass the event horizon. is that another way to define the event horizon? the point where time stops.
Time dilation makes my head hurt.
1 reply →
> but there may be no singularity because it takes matter an infinite amount of time to reach the center due to time dilation effects.
Wouldn't that just mean that the singularity is located infinitely far into the future?
Isn't it another way of saying that the singularity is never going to exist?
It's not quite true that everything feels normal. If I am standing with my feet toward the singularity, my hand cannot move above my head, the best it can do is fall toward the singularity slower than my head does. Especially at very slow speeds this has some very weird physical effects, not the least of which is the immediate impossibility of all systems that make you 'you' continuing to function.
Is this true?
My understanding is that for extremely large black holes the tidal forces are negligible near the event horizon. So things should function pretty much the same other than you can't move in reverse and get out.
If two rockets fall past the horizon at the same time, one accelerating forward towards the singularity, and the other accelerating backwards away from the singularity, then shouldn't the distance between the rockets increase, even though they are both moving inexorably forward?
If the tidal forces are low, I'd assume that my muscles are still strong enough to "slow down my hand enough" to move it above my head.
nor can you swivel your head to look backwards, as all the particles in your head are tidal locked in a falling trajectory towards the center
How so?
The black hole has two conceptual parts - the event horizon and the singularity. The event horizon is a one-way imaginary shell where once you pass it, you will end up at the singularity which is a point at the center of the event horizon. It’s the hole in black hole. Because the radius of the spherical horizon grows linearly with mass, but the size of the hole is fixed at effectively 0, it allows for a bit of sightseeing on your way to impending doom if the mass of the hole is large enough.
This is also the light barrier where light can no longer escape the gravitational forces (causing the blackness of the black hole).
Your “sightseeing tour” would be a kaleidoscope of light as it brushes past you on its way to the singularity.
3 replies →
One of the more mind bending aspects of this is how the horizon becomes inescapable. The singularity is the only “forward” that exists anymore. You cannot conceivably go anywhere else. Every direction becomes “in”.
5 replies →