← Back to context

Comment by philipallstar

1 day ago

> the divine right if kings (and incredibly closely related when that property is inherited!)

These seem to be very different indeed. You only need to be able to own and give property to have inheritance.

If your property is owned by a monarch or de facto the state, and you work your lifetime to rent it from them, then you don't get inheritance.

The similarity between divine right of kings and inheritance is that an unearned is transferred via circumstances of birth.

Your statements seem to extend that further: If you rent an apartment, you the property is owned by an landlord (lord is literally in the title!) and passed down by their wishes. Similarly if you work for Walmart for life, the company is owned and passed down by the Waltons. In these cases the property rights extend beyond life and are transferred via circumstances of birth, while the rights of labor end.

Interesting that IP rights are ended by death (or death+n years) as well. This line of reasoning suggests maybe that should apply to all property.