Comment by godelski
4 days ago
I promise you you misread. I think this is probably the problem sentence
>>>> The vast majority of smart people I know are very peaceful.
I'll also add that the vast majority of people I know are very peaceful. But neither of these means I don't know malicious people. You'd need to change "The vast majority" to "Every" for this to be the conclusion. I'm not discounting malicious smart people, I'm pointing out that it is a weird assumption to make when most people we know are kind and peaceful.
The second comment is explicit though
>> So we can't conclude that greater intelligence results in greater malice.
This is not equivalent to "We can conclude that greater intelligence results in less malice." Those are completely different claims.
No comments yet
Contribute on Hacker News ↗