Comment by furyofantares

It's really unclear that any findings with these systems would transfer to a hypothetical situation where some conscious AI system is created. I feel there are good reasons to find it very unlikely that scaling alone will produce consciousness as some emergent phenomenon of LLMs.

I don't mind starting early, but feel like maybe people interested in this should get up to date on current thinking about consciousness. Maybe they are up to date on that, but reading reports like this, it doesn't feel like it. It feels like they're stuck 20+ years ago.

I'd say maybe wait until there are systems that are more analogous to some of the properties consciousness seems to have. Like continuous computation involving learning memory or other learning over time, or synthesis of many streams of input as resulting from the same source, making sense of inputs as they change [in time, or in space, or other varied conditions].

Once systems that are pointing in those directions are starting to be built, where there is a plausible scaling-based path to something meaningfully similar to human consciousness. Starting before that seems both unlikely to be fruitful and a good way to get you ignored.