← Back to context

Comment by JambalayaJimbo

3 days ago

I work on brain dead crud apps much of my time and get nothing from LLMs.

Try Claude Code. You’ll literally be able to automate 90% of the coding part of your job.

  • We really need to add some kind of risk to people making these claims to make it more interesting. I listened to the type of advice you're giving here on more occasions than I can remember, at least once for every major revision of every major LLM and always walked away frustrated because it hindered me more than it helped.

    > This is actually amazing now, just use [insert ChatGPT, GPT-4, 4.5, 5, o1, o3, Deepseek, Claude 3.5, 3.9, Gemini 1, 1.5, 2, ...] it's completely different from Model(n-1) you've tried.

    I'm not some mythical 140 IQ 10x developer and my work isn't exceptional so this shouldn't happen.

    • The dark secret no one from the big providers wants to admit is that Claude is the only viable coding model. Everything else descends into a mess of verbose spaghetti full of hallucinations pretty quickly. Claude is head and shoulders above the rest and it isn't even remotely close, regardless of what any benchmark says.

      3 replies →

  • I've been working on macOS and Windows drivers. Can't help but disagree.

    Because of the absolute dearth of high-quality open-source driver code and the huge proliferation of absolutely bottom-barrel general-purpose C and C++, the result is... Not good.

    On the other hand, I asked Claude to convert an existing, short-ish Bash script to idiomatic PowerShell with proper cmdlet-style argument parsing, and it returned a decent result that I barely had to modify or iterate on. I was quite impressed.

    Garbage in, garbage out. I'm not altogether dismissive of AI and LLMs but it is really necessary to know where and what their limits are.

    • I'm pretty sure the GP referred to GGP's "brain dead CRUD apps" when they talked about automating 90% of the work.

I found the opposite - I am able to get 50% improvement in productivity for day to day coding (mix of backend, frontend), mostly in Javascript but have helped in other languages. But you have to carefully review though - and have extremely well written test cases if you have to blindly generate or replace existing code.