← Back to context

Comment by swe_dima

19 days ago

There goes one of the main arguments why I've been using Android over iPhone

If anything, this is even worse than what Apple does. iPhone users frequently argue that the inability to install arbitrary software is a feature in their eyes, one of the things that attracts them to the platform. I disagree with their argument, but in fairness I must admit Apple has never pretended that an iPhone is a device you control. They have always been very up front that it is a curated experience, their way or the highway. It's distasteful to me but they're honest about it. What Google is doing is a bait and switch to so many users who chose their platform specifically because it was open.

Yes, and that may be something Google does care about in the end. If Android becomes as closed and as controlled as iOS, why Android??

  • Because most of us live in countries where an iPhone is two months salary at least, or a contract bound to several years before it can be cancelled, while Android is usually half of that, with the freedom of pre-pay.

I also remember the early war between Androids and the iPhone. The main argument was that you don't need Google's permission to run applications.