← Back to context

Comment by tliltocatl

6 months ago

> I feel qualified to say this LLM is not capable of it.

This LLM have been demonstrated to be not capable, but there are no known reason why a LLM cannot dismiss such an order as nonsense - and you were claiming in the original comment that "LLMs do not possess any sort of understanding" and "These. Are not. Intelligent. Machines." A LLM fine-tuned to reject nonsensical requests would certainly be able to do so (another question is how well that would generalize - but then human aren't perfect in that regard either).

To be clear - I do not think LLMs are the universal solution to everything as they are being advertised. They do lack some unknown important component to intelligence. But using such anthropomorphic terms is really pointless - you are basically claiming "they will never be capable of doing something because they never will".