← Back to context

Comment by ranyume

1 month ago

>why shouldn’t Netflix have the right to choose who they distribute content to?

power asymmetry

There are dozens of sources of online streaming entertainment, and its not exactly a vital good.

  • Sure, Netflix may not be as important as, say, housing, food, or whatever else, but I think there is something to be said about the cultural importance of [at the very least some] film and television.

    There's a lot of media worth studying, analyzing, and preserving. And in that sense, between the constant churn of catalog items, exclusive content, and the egregious DRM, I think these sorts of streaming services are, unfortunately, kind of harmful.

    • Doesn't your second paragraph run against the grain of your first? If streaming services like Netflix are harmful then we should avoid using them. Thus it should not be important for our freedom-preserving computers to be able to access Netflix.

      Now, if you want to do an in-depth study of film and television material as a whole, you're actually better off avoiding Netflix and making use of archives such as public libraries, university libraries, and the Internet Archive.

      2 replies →

  • Yeah, there are a lot of torrent sites! Netflix doens't want my business anymore, I don't really care.

  • There exist dozens of online services where you can store your photos, doesn't mean companies should be allowed to do whatever they want with your photos...

TBH I don't care if Netflix wants to abuse such an asymmetry. I don't need Netflix in my life, so I'll just cancel my subscription(already have). I honestly don't want my lawmakers to spend even a second thinking about Netflix when we have so many large issues in the world right now. If we were talking about something like financial services where I have to engage I would be more sympathetic.

  • Capital doesn't really care what you want, it will exert control regardless. So in this case Netflix will continue to be part of capital that normalizes the need for DRM to access videos, write IP law, and generally force you into either accepting the world they want or forcing you to become a hermit.

    Edit: i mean to say this is true whether or not you've even heard of the company.