Comment by jMyles
5 months ago
> Megacorps hoarding your data and oppressive governments are part of the nature of the universe‽
No, I _certainly_ didn't intend to suggest that. In fact, I think that the proliferation of vision is likely to bring about an end to those institutions.
> I agree that the camera is not the problem per se, but your framing is a bit strange. There's more to a camera than passively receiving photons.
Of course, but those properties (namely, storage) are shared widely. At some very low-but-experimentally-verifiable-level, photons are force carriers for many of the most easily observed phenomena in our reality.
From that, I think it's probably the peaceful and radical way to derive that, as time moves forward, the universe (and the human condition in particular) is likely to gain vision and not lose it.
Cameras will get better and smaller. Storage will get faster and cheaper and more distributed. The photons in the public sphere will be captured with ever-increasing fidelity.
When all the public sphere is recorded, and all the recordings are available to everyone's analysis, can we overcome despotic tendencies, corruption, and police brutality, and eventually statism itself?
I think that the answer is 'yes'. So I am very cautious about shifting the blame onto the (inevitably widening) vision instead of the institution. As vision grows, the need for police is decreased (and thus, the need for an abolitionist movement is increased). That's the prize on which I hope we keep our... eye.
> When all the public sphere is recorded, and all the recordings are available to everyone's analysis, can we overcome despotic tendencies, corruption, and police brutality, and eventually statism itself?
No because not everyone can afford to do all of that.
I'm not sure what you're suggesting here; I don't think I made that a prerequisite of any theory.
Frankly, it sounds now like _you_ are the one defending the existence of megacorps and states, on the basis that nobody else will have the capability to be a watcher of public spaces.