← Back to context

Comment by gingerBill

3 months ago

I already know all that, that's why we are being very conservative and slow when it comes to figuring out what is meant to be in 1.0.

5 comments

gingerBill

Reply
Ygg2  3 months ago

I don't think it will matter. There will be things people want that Odin won't have in the vendor package list.

Then those people will have to manage dependencies, which is a hell on its own. Which will cause problems. Because people are super lazy so they will automate it. In the end only thing no package manager gets you is multiple package managers to juggle.

Many languages started without package managers and eventually got them - Java, JavaScript, Python, C, C++

  • gingerBill  3 months ago

    Again, I am not against third party packages, and manual management of dependencies just slows down your progression to hell. There is no "solution" to this problem, only trade-offs.

    I know people are lazy and will automate hell. That's the entire point of the article: not everything that can be automated ought to be automated.

    And the argument about multiple package managers to juggle is only the case IFF there are multiple competing ones, which with Odin, I honestly doubt it would happen if we enforced what a package is in the language. I just don't want to officially endorse one ever because I do view them to be evil.

    And I don't care many languages started without them, I am not going to give in.

    • Ygg2  3 months ago

      > I honestly doubt it would happen if we enforced what a package is in the language. I just don't want to officially endorse one ever because I do view them to be evil.

      I don't see how changing package definition is going to help. JS had no concept of package and it was bolted on with NPM. If Odin becomes big enough, the community will override the will of the author.

      Plus I don't see huge benefits to not having a package manager other than saving disk space.

      Security isn't that much meaningfully better than NPM.

      Trust problem exists regardless of package manager.

      And people aren't far to trusting, but far too lazy. And importing packages gets job done quickly.

      2 replies →