← Back to context

Comment by huem0n

3 days ago

I've been wanting something like this for a long time. There's a lot of ways this could go wrong, but I hope it works.

I'd especially love a video platform using this model. I can't afford patreon for every YouTube channel, but I'd love to pay 10¢ per hour of video watched.

$0.10 per hour is already WAY more than a creator usually gets from your viewing. I'd happily pay that amount for good youtube-like content. Creators would love it because it's far more money than they get now. Consumers would like it because for a lot of people it's cheaper than a subscription, and they could forgo ads

Yes, Small Transfers can be used for pay-per-view or pay-per-minute billing models.

The platform's biggest risk that I see is a customer defaulting after using a merchant's service. The platform currently mitigates that with Stripe Radar, 3-D Secure, and spending caps, but I'm keen to hear anything specific you're thinking about.

  • > customer defaulting after using a merchant's service

    I think the defaulting rate would just get baked into the asking price. But I'm assuming there isn't a way to repeatedly systematically default to get unlimited free content.

    • Each customer already has a limit on the amount they can owe before we require payment. Each customer account also requires a unique payment method, which must pass Stripe Radar and 3-D Secure checks. We plan to add more checks in the future.

  • I don’t know if it defeats the purpose but you could require an upfront, refundable deposit.

    • Requiring money upfront would classify the platform as an e-money institution, which is highly problematic from the legal perspective.

      9 replies →

10¢ per hour seems low to me — I’d happily pay ~$1 per hour. $10 per week is less than I currently pay for subscriptions, and I don’t want to spend more than 10 hrs per week watching video anyway.

  • Where YouTube is my movie player and podcast player and general video player, all of which is done at 2x speed I can't imagine paying $4-6/day for YouTube.

    Just my commute listening to a podcast that I downloaded before leaving would cost me $1.50 each way? Nah I'll keep my subscription thanks.