Comment by lubujackson
2 days ago
There's a lot that goes into it. Before Facebook was Friendster. Which failed spectacularly because they tried to have some sort of n-squared graph of friends that took thw whole thing down. What FB got right in the early days was it didn't crash. We take that for granted now in the age of cloud everything.
Also, there was Classmates.com. A way for people to connect with old friends from high school. But it was a subscription service and few people were desperate enough to pay.
So it's wasn't just the idea waiting around but idea with the right combination of factors, user-growth on the Internet, etc.
And don't forget Facebook's greatest innovation - requiring a .edu email to register. This happened at a time when people were hesitant to tie their real world personas with the scary Internet, and it was a huge advantage: a great marketing angle, a guarantee of 1-to-1 accounts to people, and a natural rate limiter of adoption.
There's always a trail of competitors who almost got the magic formula right, but for some feature or luck or timing or money or something.
The giant win comes from many stars aligning. Luck is a factor - it's not everything but it plays a role - luck is the description of when everything fell into place at just the right time on top of hard work and cleverness and preparedness.
Google Search <-- AltaVista, Lycos, Yahoo
Facebook <-- MySpace, Friendster
iPod <-- MP3 players (Rio, Creative)
iPhone <-- BlackBerry, Palm, Windows Mobile
Minecraft <-- Infiniminer
Amazon Web Services <-- traditional hosting
Windows (<-- Mac OS (1984), Xerox PARC
Android <-- Symbian, Windows Mobile, Palm
YouTube <-- Vimeo, DailyMotion
Zoom <-- WebEx, Skype, GoToMeeting
Before iPods and iPhones, people thought that those spaces were "solved" and there was no room for "innovation"
mp3 players were commodity items, you could buy one for a couple of dollars, fill it up with your favourite music format (stolen) and off you went.
Phones too - Crackberry was the epitome of sophistication, and technological excellence.
Jobs/Apple didn't create anything "new" in those spheres, instead he added desireability, fancy UX that caught peoples' attentions
Not a guarantee. I used to find abandoned .edu mailing lists so I could create accounts at arbitrary schools.