← Back to context

Comment by newpavlov

5 hours ago

IIUC graphitosis, silicosis, and black lung require to inhale ungodly amounts of dust. It's orders of magnitude more than we can expect from flaking-based trace contamination.

Why do you expect a different result from "tiny sheets of graphene flaking off everywhere from nanocoatings" compared to the same flaking from graphite smeared across paper?

Pencil graphite breaks off in very large chunks and when you look at them in a microscope the particle size is in the micrometers. Those particles are too big to easily penetrate cells or deep tissue. You understand correctly about the dust issue.

Nanosheets are a different story and I’m worried that the graphene produced for industrial applications will be much smaller, flake off much easier in the field as distinct sheets like from abrasion, and stay airborne for longer. In that form they’re likely to behave like asbestos and the evidence is already pretty strong that they do.