Comment by heavyset_go

> We already had this argument when Oracle sued Google over Java.

"It's boilerplate therefore it isn't IP" isn't the argument that was made by Google, nor is it the argument that the case was decided upon.

It was decided that Google's use of the API met the four determining factors used by courts to ascertain whether use of IP is fair use. The court found that even though it was Oracle's copyrighted IP, it was still fair use to use it in the way Google did.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_LLC_v._Oracle_America,_...