← Back to context

Comment by 1vuio0pswjnm7

3 months ago

What happens if the computer owner disables Google Play Services along with the Play Store and keeps the phone offline

(Own experients conducted over the years make this a "rhetorical question" meaning I already know the answer)

Not every app requires Play Services and internet access

(Online commentators sometimes try to argue that all apps, even offlines ones, "require" Play Services otherwise they cannot be updated automatically, highlighting the significance of "automatic updates" in steering debates about Android. Own experiments show that many if not most apps work fine without Play Services and can be updated manually if desired)

Not every phone is used for banking or other "government services"

(For example, some owners have mulltiple phones. Some owners may have phones with older versions of mobile OS that may be used for experiments)

Not every computer owner is the same

(For example, most phone owners do not install any apps at all. Of those that do, most use "app stores", not so-called "sideloading")

HN replies are likely to invoke "security" as a retort to any suggestion of decision-making and control being placed with the computer owner