← Back to context

Comment by ethbr1

3 months ago

Or the story about the BillG review and Excel date math.

https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2006/06/16/my-first-billg-rev...

Which, incidentally, is a great primer for younger developers on both what obsessive software quality looks like and why datetimes are a hard problem.

I remember how date math is special there. A simple question: 30-01-2024 plus one month - what is the result date?

  • Well I had to try this in Excel and (after fighting the input format), it gave me

      2024-01-30 -> 2024-01-29
      2025-01-30 -> 2025-01-28
    

    Fun. There is so much ambiguity in what “one month” means.

    Polars has an offset-by function which is a bit more explicit about how you want to handle date math. “Calendar date” vs number of days.

    Edit: just ran polars and I’m not in love with its answer either.