Comment by SamBam
3 days ago
No, it sounds like the author is well aware of that, and is instead just trying to get a read on what the gov's various systems are saying about him, so he can stay well within buffers of that.
He explicitly says that none of his data on the app would convince an official.
The point is - while all of these systems are fuzzy at the edges, that is not a bug. Letting people reside in a few countries at the same time, and to pick a tax residency like a new winter jacket is a non-objective for the border, tax and residency systems.
It's actually relatively simple to follow the rules that lead you down the well estabilished residency paths if you do the opposite of what the article suggests and leave enough of a buffer for every required number, so you don't need to think about it and the precise count can be handwaved by the officials.
Conversly, if you try to minmax the rules, you might find that most important systems still have an arbitrary human decision maker, who simply decides whether to apply a complex ruleset to the letter, or to be lenient.
> No, it sounds like the author is well aware of that, and is instead just trying to get a read on what the gov's various systems are saying about him, so he can stay well within buffers of that.
You don't need an app for that. You just behave like a normal person.
> You just behave like a normal person.
?? I'm a normal person, and I don't need to count my days in and out of a country, I just take vacations when I like.
If OP did that, they'd lose their visa.
It sounds like you've never known anyone on a green card, or waiting for citizenship, or on a visa that requires a certain number of days in the country.
> To apply for British citizenship, you need to prove you were physically in the UK on your application date but five years ago.
This is an insane bureaucratic requirement (to have been in the country exactly 5 years on the day prior), and not someone the vast majority of people need to worry about. How does "just behave like a normal person" help keep you on the right side of multiple overlapping Kafkaesque requirements?
Hard disagree. You accidentally break an immigration rule, you face the consequences (if you get caught and the officer is not letting it slide).
No amount of "behaving like a normal person" (whatever that means) is going to save you in that situation.