← Back to context

Comment by mulmen

3 days ago

Seems superficial. If a simple concept is presented in a complex way what did you actually learn?

Often, if the concept is presented in a more complex way the reason is that the author wants to emphasize and explain how the concept relates in a non-trivial way to some other deep concept; thus you learn a lot more than when the author explains things in the most simple (and shallow) way.

  • IMO the most common reason why something is presented in a more complex way is that it is badly explained.

    Of course, most common or not, each case is different.

    • Also speaks to a lack of understanding on the author's part; people who truly understand some subject are generally much more adept at explaining it in simpler terms – ie without adding complexity beyond the subject's essential complexity

  • I don’t see how that is beneficial. If a simple concept relates to a complex one then explain the complexity, don’t add it.

    • > If a simple concept relates to a complex one then explain the complexity, don’t add it.

      So write a text of at least 500 pages to explain the complexity. :-)