← Back to context

Comment by ang_cire

4 hours ago

Waymo cars are new. Wait until their fleets are 10+ years old. They'll have all the same bad maintenance issues that airplanes, semis, rental cars, and any other company-owned vehicles have.

I expect that Waymo will have standards. In theory Uber does as well, but since the drivers own their own cars they can't enforce them. A 15 year old car that has been well maintained is still safe to have on the road (within the limits of the safety systems on board), while a 6 year old car with a lot of miles that hasn't been maintained can be deadly.

Really? I fly a lot and Part 121 commercial airliners seem to be pretty well maintained.

  • Very few airliners depart in perfect working order. There is a "MEL" (minimum equipment list) that details which systems can be inop and still operate the flight.

    • Sure, however that's why there's a minimum. The problem is that lots of GA aeroplanes aren't that well maintained.

      People aren't on the whole suicidal, they're not going to go up in a plane they expect to kill them, but they absolutely will push their luck in privately owned planes and statistically that doesn't end well. Go see the figures for yourself, inadequate maintenance isn't first on the list for why GA crash rates are too high, but it's on there.

      1 reply →

    • None of that stuff really impacts safety. They're not leaving the gate with under inflated tires or expired engine oil.