Comment by vunderba

14 hours ago

Outside the time frame of being able to edit my original reply, but I've finally re-run the Text-to-Image portion of the site through NB Pro.

  Results

  gpt-image-1: 10 / 12 
  Nano Banana Pro: 9 / 12
  Nano Banana: 8 / 12

It's worth mentioning that even though it only scored slightly better than the original NB, many of the images are significantly better looking.

https://genai-showdown.specr.net?models=nb,nbp

3 comments

vunderba

happyopossum 8 hours ago

Awesome test suite. For the maze though, not sure it’s fair to knock it for extra dashed lines as the prompt didn’t specify that only the correct path should have one…

Wyverald 14 hours ago

thanks for the update. One small note: for the d20 test, NB Pro had duplications of 13 and 17 too, not just 19.

vunderba 11 hours ago

Good catch - I've been staring at these images so long day I'm starting to get the equivalent of "Tetris Effect"!
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetris_effect