← Back to context Comment by peppersghost93 2 days ago They are if they happen under capitalist states, which is what the US is. 3 comments peppersghost93 Reply rchaud 2 days ago So if something is declared "capitalist", it maintains that state in perpetuity, regardless of the actions it takes in reality? peppersghost93 1 day ago That is not what I said, nor implied. In the US the means of production are owned by private individuals. It is capitalist. You may not like the form it's taking but it is what it is. wahnfrieden 2 days ago No, but it is a materialist analysis of capitalism in practice, rather than unrealized idealism
rchaud 2 days ago So if something is declared "capitalist", it maintains that state in perpetuity, regardless of the actions it takes in reality? peppersghost93 1 day ago That is not what I said, nor implied. In the US the means of production are owned by private individuals. It is capitalist. You may not like the form it's taking but it is what it is. wahnfrieden 2 days ago No, but it is a materialist analysis of capitalism in practice, rather than unrealized idealism
peppersghost93 1 day ago That is not what I said, nor implied. In the US the means of production are owned by private individuals. It is capitalist. You may not like the form it's taking but it is what it is.
wahnfrieden 2 days ago No, but it is a materialist analysis of capitalism in practice, rather than unrealized idealism
So if something is declared "capitalist", it maintains that state in perpetuity, regardless of the actions it takes in reality?
That is not what I said, nor implied. In the US the means of production are owned by private individuals. It is capitalist. You may not like the form it's taking but it is what it is.
No, but it is a materialist analysis of capitalism in practice, rather than unrealized idealism