← Back to context

Comment by autoexec

2 days ago

It's far more likely to discourage me and my friends from staying at that hotel entirely.

How many people consider what a bathroom looks like before booking a hotel room? I can't say I've ever done so.

  • Actively? Almost no one.

    But I absolutely check out google maps reviews, and a single review saying that the hotel did not have a proper door on the bathroom would guarantee I would not stay there.

    Even traveling alone it's a clear indication they have no respect for their guests, and it's a significant hygiene issue.

    • > Even traveling alone it's a clear indication they have no respect for their guests, and it's a significant hygiene issue.

      I feel like if you consider lack of a door a significant hygiene issue, you probably just shouldn’t be staying in hotels. These rooms aren’t being sanitized between guests, they are pretty dirty.

      2 replies →

  • Until recently, you never had to think about it. But as it becomes more common it will become something you might want to consider.

    • And until then they will milk as much money as possible. If there is outrage or they see sales dropping, a few thousand dollars per hotel will replace those rooms with doors leaving with net profit and steady shareholder growth. Some statistical analysis ppt made by some mid level MBA must have proposed this and got a promotion.

      2 replies →

    • > Until recently, you never had to think about it. But as it becomes more common it will become something you might want to consider.

      This is closely related to a phenomenon I don't understand.

      Pretty much every proposed regulatory change (for example: letting drivers pump their own gas at gas stations) meets a fierce counterargument that says "currently, no one considers this situation at all because only one state of affairs is legal. If that thoughtlessness continues after we legalize other possibilities, TERRIBLE THINGS COULD HAPPEN!".

      But obviously this protasis† can never occur and so it doesn't matter what's in the apodosis.

      https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/protasis#English (2)

  • I definitely do not return to a hotel where the bathroom was sub-par...

    And likewise I absolutely return to a hotel where the bathroom was good when going back to a city.

    I'm mostly talking about the water pressure for the shower here, but you get the idea.

  • Depends on how long I stay. For a two week vacation I definitely check out the layout.

    For a city trip I basically accept anything with a bed and running water.

  • I want a hot bath after a long day. I don't have one at home so you best believe I'm having one when I'm travelling.

  • It could discourage repeat customers?

    There is a website dedicated to it. It would take someone posting that to a few social media accounts and for hotel search sites to put "has an almost see through glass bathroom door" result category, and I think it could turn from a sneaky money maker into a reason people avoid the place.

  • Really? It's one of my main discriminators. The quality of the bathroom is the highest signal indicator of the quality of the hotel. I look for a stone shower basin, a rainhead, a bath tub, or at a least glass shower door... if it looks bolted onto a plastic box, I'm not staying there.

    If they're cheaping out on the shower then I'm not going to trust the mattress is clean or the linens are soft.

  • My wife is keenly interested in whether or not there is a bathtub. Keenly.

    • Mine is as well. So far the only way I have found to locate such increasingly-rare rooms is booking.com followed by calling the hotel. For all their sins, Booking at least lets you search for hotels that have bathtubs in any rooms at all.

      Aside from rinsing off after a pool or ocean swim, or when she is actually dirty (e.g., after yard work), I think I have known her to voluntarily take three or four showers in 25 years together.

  • You don't, because you expect there to be a toilet, a sink, a shower, towels, a mirror etc. there. There's nothing to consider, it's just expected to be there. Same for the bathroom door.

    But if i got burned once or twice by a room without a bathroom door, i'd start checking that too and avoiding places that don't have them.

  • I do. Most of my travel is alone for work so I don’t care about a door, but I always call ahead and refuse to book hotels with shower curtains.

It sometimes feels like hotels are taunting us: "we're behaving like a cartel, whaddaya gonna do? Regulate us!? We've already tricked you into thinking that's socialism!"

  • It's a weird flex for a time when airbnb and vrbo have options all over the place.

    • With hotels you're playing the lottery but there is generally a baseline consistent with the brand of the hotel.

      With those two you're also playing the lottery but there is no baseline.

      With a hotel, you're also generally paying when you check-in and can thus refuse a subpar room and argue with a real, mostly-reasonable person.

      With those two, you get charged before you even enter the place and any arguments will be with a bot or a call center drone in a third-world country pretending to be one.

      1 reply →

  • >whaddaya gonna do? Regulate us!? We've already tricked you into thinking that's socialism!"

    More like "I dare you, regulation will only further increase our moat"

    • I'm gonna go ahead and suggest that the "bathrooms must have doors" public health regulation is unlikely to increase any moats.

      4 replies →