Comment by ta12653421
4 months ago
>> There is even a recent paper that points out that LLMs will never become AGI.
can you share a link?
4 months ago
>> There is even a recent paper that points out that LLMs will never become AGI.
can you share a link?
Took me a while to find again, as there are a lot of such papers in this area.
https://www.arxiv.org/pdf/2511.18517
A single author, in a physics department. Seems unlikely to be groundbreaking or authoritative.
Welcome to the world of papers. Have a read and get back to us. Dismissing out of hand is rarely constructive.
1 reply →
Ad hominem right out of the gate? Really?
Is this AI paper written by a reputable subject matter expert? It seems to be written by a physicist and also be the only academic work by this author in English
So you are dismissing it because of that? Certainly read the paper first and attack the arguments, not the author. It even has 10 pages of citations.
I have read it. It is nothing new on the subject, but it was just the recent paper I saw on HN and the person was asking for the link.
The crux is an LLM is and can never be intelligent in the sense of an AGI. It is easier to think of it as a way to store and retrieve knowledge.
3 replies →
Absolutely. If it is not written by someone who has real world experience and deep knowledge it has no more value than a HN comment.
2 replies →