Comment by lvspiff
18 hours ago
I setup real life accounts with etrade and fidelity using the etrade auto portfolio, fidelity i have an advisor for retirement, and then i did a basket portfolio as well but used ms365 with grok 5 and various articles and strategies to pick a set of 5 etfs that would perform similarly to the exposure of my other two.
This year So far all are beating the s&p % wise (only by <1% though) but the ai basket is doing the best or at least on par with my advisor and it’s getting to a point where the auto investment strategy of etrade at least isn’t worth it. Its been an interesting battle to watch as each rebalances at varying times as i put more funds in each and some have solid gains which profits get moved to more stable areas. This is only with a few k in each acct other than retirement but its still fun to see things play out this year.
In other words though im not surprised at all by the results. Ai isnt something to day trade with still but it is helpful in doing research for your desired risk exposure long term imo.
How much are the expense ratios on those etfs you chose, though? I mean, Vanguard, Fidelity, Blackrock, and others have extremely low cost funds and etfs and it has been shown year after year and decade after decade that you can't beat their average returns over the long term. Indexing works for a reason. Beating something by 1%? It's not even worth it if your costs and taxes are higher than that.