Comment by 47282847
2 days ago
I honestly don’t see the harm about removing the lending period for my personal reading. It will only make me check out and read more books. Can you detail the harm I am causing? It’s like making photocopies of books for my own use, which is still legal.
The chain of causality is about one link long: If libraries become common vectors for privacy, the powers that be will end libraries. https://time.com/6266147/internet-archive-copyright-infringe...
Photocopying an entire book is, in fact, against the law in most cases: https://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/academic-and-education...
Selfish people like yourself are why we can't have nice things. Either pay for your books or pirate them outright from bittorrent.
1. I am not in the USA.
2. You’re pointing at the legal code that is about exceptions for library liability. 17 U.S.C. § 108 doesn’t say anything about me making a personal copy.
I don’t yet understand your one-link argument about privacy and how it relates to this discussion. I read that you would prefer if I were to directly download a copy from a shadow library instead of lending it from my local library.
yes, yes I would prefer that you buy drugs from a drug dealer instead of stealing them from a hospital.
*piracy
(but they also don't like privacy laws around libraries)