← Back to context

Comment by sallveburrpi

2 days ago

And? I don’t see the direct correlation. The same might be true if we get a China-dominated century - or not who tf knows…

> or not who tf knows

Right, because counterfactuals aren’t provable. It doesn’t seem to stop people from confidently stating that American hegemony was worse than the alternatives.

We know it worked well, that the entire world seems to be better off now than before ww2. We know that west Germany did far better than east Germany. We know Japan did far better than the Asian states under the USSR’s influence. We know that things went pretty damned well overall for the whole NATOsphere after ww2.

We know WW3 didn’t happen.

We don’t know how it would have gone if it were another country “in charge” or how it would have gone if nobody was “in charge” to the degree the US was.

So just saying “Pax Americana was a pox on the world” is such an utterly asinine statement I don’t even know how to begin to address it, other than to file it under “trolls gonna troll.”