Comment by xen0

Your real commit history is irrelevant. I don't care too much about how you came to a particular state.

The overall project history though, the clarity of changes made, and that bisecting reliably works are important to me.

Or another way; the important unit is whatever your unit of code review is. If you're not reviewing and checking individual commits, they're just noise in the history; the commit messages are not clear and I cannot reliably bisect on them (since nobody is checking that things build).