← Back to context

Comment by esseph

19 hours ago

> Reddit is fucking miserable

Reddit is the town bar, the popular one.

Some people love the town bar! :)

Some people hate the town bar! :(

Things like this can often be assessed on a macro level. When you start to get the number of users sites like Facebook have and sites like Reddit claim they have, you end up with content that's reflective of a broad sample of society. You do have that on Facebook, you do not have that on Reddit.

I suspect Reddit is intentionally overcounting by doing things like counting multiple devices as different users, multiple accounts as different users, making minimal efforts to remove bots, counting dynamic IPs as distinct users, and so on. You could even count API callers as users, but that is stretching the limits of plausible deniability. The thing is - their content isn't reflective of the popular town bar, it's representative of an insular clubhouse with some small rooms in the backyard for 'normies.'

  • If you look at their "all accounts" it's over 650,000,000.

    Around 250,000,000 is monthly user usage, which would be for one or more accounts.

    And if course, like every site, a percentage that keep the thing going (around 35,000,000 daily logins).

    It's one of the top sites on the internet and has been for a very long time.

  • I tried to start using Reddit. None of my friends had ever heard of it or wanted to use it, and I soon lost interest in it.

    From my little experience of using it, it seems that its main audience is the mentally retarded or just children under 11 years old.

    The same questions are asked all the time. It wasn't difficult for me to find a search on the site for why they don't use it?

    There is a lot of nonsense in the comments/answers, which they state with full confidence.

    And there was also a feeling that there are rarely disagreements in discussions, even if there are minor differences, everyone adheres to a single line, often related to the topic/name of the subreddit.

    I found several people creating content that I was interested in, but some of the posts on the page were hidden and it was easier to follow them on YouTube or blogs.

    In general, searching for valuable posts or comments is like digging through manure to find gold.

    And even if you find a clever idea or a good technical hint, it was often easier to find it just by reading the documentation. It's the same with interesting posts. If it's something worthwhile, then it will be on twitter, blog, YouTube, social networks or in some forums.

    I'm not talking about advertising every second post, or even among the comments. Disabling ad blocking was a mistake.

    > it's representative of an insular clubhouse with some small rooms in the backyard for 'normies.'

    A very appropriate definition. It's not even interesting to discuss something on Reddit. If your opinion or thought coincides with the ideology of the subreddit, then you will have a lot of likes. If it don't match, you get dislikes, insults, or worse, no response.

    In general, I did not find any benefit for myself on Reddit and I am unlikely to return there, it is a waste of energy and effort.

Reddit is a bunch of bar districts in a large city. You can find any sort of bar you want. Some of the bars you'll love. Some of them you'll hate. Some of them will make you say "what the hell is any of this?"

It's an almost infinite variety. Fractal even with how many subreddits are the results of splits from an older subreddit.

  • You can find any sort of bar you want, but all of them are owned by the same shady company which waters down the drinks, are involved in secret backroom deals which sometimes results in things like selling your personal info or in bars being closed without notice. They also refuse to give the bouncers the training and resources they need which leaves many bars full of jerks who shouldn't have made it inside in the first place, while in other bars you can find yourself thrown out for no reason at all.

    It's kind of like an American grocery store where you have shelf after shelf filled with different brand names and products in all kinds of colors and flavors, but they're all owned by one of three corporations so it really doesn't matter which product you buy, you're still supporting the same assholes who will gladly poison you if it'll increase their profits by a fraction of a cent, so naturally most of your choice comes down to the flavor of the poison.

No. I'm very specifically saying (contrary to your implication) that it's the management of the bar which is the problem

HN loves to do this. "Platforms are mirrors held up to society". No, not always. Sometimes there really is unnecessary executive top-down control